The New York Mets entered the offseason with expectations as heavy as their payroll history. Instead, the winter has opened with frustration, uncertainty, and a growing sense of impatience. Losing Pete Alonso and Edwin Díaz in free agency was never going to go unnoticed, but the lack of immediate counterpunches has fueled an increasingly loud debate around the franchise.
For a team that once redefined spending norms, the optics have mattered almost as much as the moves themselves. Alonso’s departure, in particular, struck a nerve. The Mets publicly expressed interest in keeping the slugging first baseman, only to watch him walk. That gap between intention and outcome quickly became ammunition for critics questioning whether New York was pulling back.
Those questions gained traction following a column by Mike Puma of The New York Post, which framed the situation as a clear example of actions failing to match rhetoric. The piece resonated widely, especially among fans already uneasy with the Mets’ relatively quiet offseason.
As typical, the usual idiots misinterpreting a Post article on the Mets’ payroll for ’26”
Cohen steps into the spotlight
That reaction did not sit well with Steve Cohen. The Mets owner responded on social media, taking direct aim at how the article was being interpreted. “As typical, the usual idiots misinterpreting a Post article on the Mets’ payroll for ’26,”Cohen wrote. He made it clear that any suggestion of a reduced payroll misses the mark, adding that he cannot imagine the team spending less than it did last season.
The numbers help explain why the pushback was so strong. According to Spotrac, the Mets carried a payroll exceeding $300 million in 2024, the highest in Major League Baseball. Forbes continues to list Cohen as the league’s wealthiest owner, a reminder that financial limitations have rarely been part of the Mets’ identity under his leadership. ESPN has also reported consistently on Cohen’s willingness to exceed luxury tax thresholds in pursuit of contention.
So far, the Mets’ moves have been measured rather than explosive. They signed reliever Devin Williams, added infielder Jorge Polanco, and swung a trade with the Texas Rangers to bring in second baseman Marcus Semien. Useful additions, but not the type that silence concerns about losing elite talent.
Still, context matters. The offseason is far from over, and the Mets have a history of striking later rather than early. New York often waits for market conditions to shift before making aggressive plays.
Cohen’s message was blunt, but clear. The Mets are not retreating. Whether that confidence translates into headline-grabbing moves will determine how this offseason is ultimately judged, and whether the noise fades or only grows louder.
Read the full article here
