Although A-Rod spoke as an analyst, several voices in the MLB world believe he could have done more to help the young Yankees shortstop, especially in a 2025 season marked by poor performance, media pressure and an injury that changed the landscape.
What did A-Rod say about Anthony Volpe?
Alex Rodriguez publicly questioned the Yankees’ offensive approach and said it was affecting the natural development of Anthony Volpe. According to his analysis, one of the player’s greatest strengths was his speed and ability to make an impact on the bases, something that had been overlooked in the Bronx.
Volpe had stolen more than 50 bases in the minors, but that facet practically disappeared in the majors. For Rodriguez, the problem went beyond the player and pointed to a “broken” organizational philosophy. As expected, the criticism was not well received in New York
Kevin Pillar questions A-Rod’s role
Alex Rodriguez’sformer Blue Jays player Kevin PillarA-Rod’sPillar
suggested that
A-RodVolpe
He can fix this, but someone like A-Rod, if he can call Anthony Volpe, take him to Miami and work with him, or fly to see him, or do whatever he wants. And if he thinks he’s someone who can help him, people do that all the time. A-Rod could have been that guy for Volpe, but instead he decided to somehow publicly criticize him. And if I were Anthony Volpe, I don’t know if I would take his call
Yankees and the example of other veterans
Within the
Yankees
organization, there are multiple examples of veterans who have actively supported the youngsters. Names such as
DJ LeMahieuBrett Gardner
, now retired, has remained close to the team, passing on his competitive mentality.
However,
Alex Rodriguez
is now an official Fox Sports analyst, and part of his job is to point out flaws and generate debate. From that perspective, his criticism of
VolpeYankees
Anthony Volpe’s numbers in 2025
Anthony Volpehe hit just .212, struck out 150 times and committed 19 defensive errorsVolpeYankees
were eliminated in the ALDS against Toronto, he underwent surgery to repair a torn labrum. This is a factor that gives another perspective to the former Yankee’s criticism.
Read the full article here
