Before any additions and in the midst of an offseason full of expectations, the New York Yankees made a decision that ignited controversy: to offer Anthony Volpe a contract for next season. The move ensures that the 24-year-old remains with the organization, a decision that has upset fans who were calling for an immediate change at the position.
Volpe is coming off an inconsistent 2025, with defensive errors, poor offensive performance and a shoulder injury that required surgery in October. Although he set personal bests in home runs (19) and RBIs (72), his .212 average and .663 OPS raised doubts about his real progression. Even so, the Yankees consider him part of the plan for 2026.
Neither mistakes nor surgery stop the bet on Volpe
The announcement broadcast by SNY confirmed that the Yankees will “tender” Anthony Volpe, meaning they will offer him a contract through the salary arbitration process. With this decision, the franchise avoids the shortstop becoming a free agent and ensures his continuity for 2026, showing the management’s confidence in his development. However, this gamble comes at a delicate time: the infielder’s recent numbers do not fully support this choice.
The fans explode and demand changes at shortstop
Bo Bichette
Discontent erupted on social media, from sarcastic comments to direct criticism of the player’s offensive inability. His playoff performance did not help either: just one hit in 15 at-bats with 11 strikeouts in the ALDS against Toronto, fueling the perception that he is not ready to take on the starting role.
With the patience of the Bronx running thin and the future of the young shortstop at the center of the debate, the 2026 season becomes a definitive test for Anthony Volpe. The Yankees are backing him, but now he will have to answer to a city that has already made it clear that it does not forgive.
Read the full article here
