The New York Yankees‘ latest playoff disappointment has reignited debate over who is truly to blame for the team’s repeated failures for the 2025 season.
While manager Aaron Boone and general manager Brian Cashman have long been the prime targets of fan frustration, a recent report suggests that the real problem lies elsewhere – within the franchise’s very structure and philosophy – and their failure to maximize Aaron Judge’s ability.
On a recent episode of The Rich Eisen Show, ESPN’sBuster Olney pointed to where the actual problem lies. In the episode, Rich Eisen asked Olney: “On behalf of all Yankee fans… why do the Yankees keep running it back?”
Olney replied: “You grew up with the Steinbrenner doctrine: if you don’t win the World Series, then your season is a failure. Well, the person who doesn’t believe in the Steinbrenner doctrine is Hal Steinbrenner. The son. He doesn’t operate that way.”
It highlights how this overreliance has turned the once-fearless Yankees into a franchise paralyzed by its own information.
It’s a criticism that has echoed throughout Yankee Stadium in recent years. Despite boasting elite talent like Aaron Judge, Juan Soto, and Gerrit Cole, the Yankees have repeatedly underperformed when it matters most.
Many around the league now believe that the team’s commitment to analytical micromanagement – from lineup construction to pitching changes – has stripped the organization of the swagger and adaptability that once defined its dynasty years.
Aaron Judge’s prime years are slipping away
No one has felt that lack of direction more acutely than Aaron Judge. Now in his early 30s, the captain continues to put up MVP-caliber numbers while carrying an offense that too often sputters around him.
Yet as the postseason failures mount, concern grows that Judge‘s prime years are being wasted by an organization unable – or unwilling – to evolve.
“I’m genuinely concerned that Aaron Judge’s talent is being ultimately wasted right now,” Eisen added, before saying that he feels Judge is “surrounded by a lineup that doesn’t get on base for him enough.”
Since his record-breaking 62-home-run season in 2022, Judge has remained the face of the franchise, embodying the kind of leadership the Yankees once built dynasties around. But even his brilliance has limits. As the report suggests, the issue isn’t effort or talent – it’s philosophy.
The analytics department’s influence reportedly stretches from scouting and player development all the way to game strategy, leaving managers like Boone little room for improvisation. That rigid approach has produced regular-season consistency but postseason paralysis, where adaptability and instinct win out over spreadsheets.
Fans and pundits have started to voice a growing fear: that Judge could become another generational talent whose career is defined more by “what could have been” than championship glory.
Can the Yankees rediscover their identity?
Fixing the problem will require more than roster tweaks. The Yankees need to rediscover the cultural DNA that once made them the sport’s most ruthless winners – a blend of aggression, accountability, and belief in their stars.
If the organization continues to hide behind numbers and models, the cost could be steep. Judge‘s legacy – and the Yankees‘ claim to being baseball’s premier franchise – hangs in the balance.
For now, the captain remains loyal and optimistic, but the frustration is growing across the fan base. The numbers may tell one story, but the scoreboard in October keeps telling another.
Unless something changes soon, Aaron Judge‘s prime could go down as one of the greatest individual eras never to be rewarded with the postseason success it deserved – and that might be the biggest failure of all.
Read the full article here
