Las Vegas holds the most valuable asset in football this offseason in the first overall pick in the 2026 NFL Draft. Indiana quarterback Fernando Mendoza appears destined to hear his name called first, giving new head coach Klint Kubiak an immediate answer at the sport’s most important position.
Yet, Kirk Herbstreit believes the Raiders might be setting up both themselves and Mendoza for failure.
The analyst’s concerns don’t stem from doubts about Mendoza‘s talent. Instead, Herbstreit questions whether Las Vegas has the foundational pieces necessary for a quarterback who succeeds through intelligence rather than elite physical tools.
“I really think he’s a guy that, the typical, we don’t have a left guard, we don’t have a right tackle, we need a couple receivers, we really need a quarterback. That’s not the guy,” Herbstreit explained on ESPN’s This is Football.
“But if you’ve got a couple tight ends, if you’ve got an offensive line you feel good about, if you got a back that’s capable, you got a few receivers, you just you need the quarterback, he’s the guy.”
Raiders have pieces but significant gaps remain
Brock Bowers gives Las Vegas one of the league’s best young tight ends, and Ashton Jeanty provides a legitimate ground threat.
Those two represent genuine building blocks. Beyond them, however, the roster looks problematic. The offensive line needs significant upgrades, and the receiving corps lacks proven playmakers outside of Bowers.
Herbstreit contrasted Mendoza with physically dominant quarterbacks who can prop up struggling teams while the organization fills roster holes around them. He specifically mentioned Justin Herbert‘s entry into the league as an example of that archetype.
“So, it depends on how you evaluate the Raiders or other teams. I just don’t think he’s like a Justin Herbert coming out of Oregon that he’s so skilled,” Herbstreit said. “We’re going to grow around him and eventually he’s good enough to keep us afloat, but eventually we’re going to become elite when we get the right pieces around him. He’s not the guy.”
The difficulty with evaluating Mendoza, according to Herbstreit, lies in projecting how mental attributes translate from college to the professional level. Physical tools show up clearly on film and testing metrics. Intelligence, anticipation and processing ability require more nuanced assessment.
“I’m not looking down at his ability. I just think he would fit in well. He’s a mind guy. He’s going to hurt you with his mind, his preparation, his processing, which I think is a very difficult thing to evaluate when it comes to a college quarterback going to the pros,” Herbstreit added.
Read the full article here
