In the midst of one of the most intense postseason series, Major League Baseball has generated controversy by appointing Alfonso Marquez as the lead umpire for Game 4 of the American League Championship Series between the Toronto Blue Jays and the Seattle Mariners
The decision has been heavily criticized by fans and analysts, who point out that Marquez is among the umpires with the least accuracy in his calls during the regular season. In a scenario where every play can define the course of the series, many believe that MLB is risking competitive integrity by not prioritizing the best performing officials.
A worrying history
According to the specialized site The WARmonger, Marquez ranks 80th out of 83 umpires in correct call percentage, which has raised concerns among fans who demand accuracy in high-caliber games such as postseason games.
Reactions on social media
Users on X rated the decision as an absolute joke and questioned the logic of MLB in allowing underperforming umpires to be present in games that define the fate of teams fighting for the championship.
The precedent of Doug Eddings
The frustration was exacerbated by Doug Eddings‘ performance in Game 2, where 24 missed calls were reported, making it the worst umpired game since 2022; now, with Marquez in the spotlight, fans fear a repeat of the chaos.
They demand higher standards
Many baseball fans have called for only umpires with the best records to be assigned to playoff games, arguing that lack of accuracy can alter the course of a series and unfairly affect teams.
A decision under scrutiny
With the Mariners leading the series 2-0 and the next games at home, the pressure on Marquez will be at its highest; any mistake could intensify the controversy and increase calls to implement technology such as the ABS system in decisive games.
Read the full article here
