The Texas Longhorns, ranked No. 1, were defeated 14-7 by the No. 3 Ohio State Buckeyes in a high-profile matchup that marked Arch Manning’s first start as the full-time quarterback. Already, the young passer is facing criticism of his performance and questions concerning his potential.
Manning, nephew of NFL legends Peyton and Eli Manning, entered the game amid widespread expectations as a potential first-overall pick in the 2026 NFL Draft and a projected “generational” talent.
Despite the buildup, his performance failed to meet those expectations. Manning completed 17 of 30 passes for 170 yards, throwing one touchdown and one interception.
A fourth-quarter play initially ruled as a second interception was overturned after review, with replays showing the ball hit the turf before the defender could secure it. Manning also recorded a 37 percent off-target rate, the highest for a Texas quarterback in a single game over the past decade, according to ESPN Research.
The matchup drew nearly 107,000 fans to the stadium, along with scouts from over a dozen NFL teams, including the Cleveland Browns.
The presence of a national audience and professional evaluators intensified scrutiny on Manning, particularly as he faced Ohio State’s well-prepared defensive unit coordinated by Matt Patricia. The Buckeyes effectively neutralized the running game, forcing Manning to rely on a passing attack that struggled for consistency.
Is there too much pressure on Manning’s shoulders?
Commentators and former players were critical of Manning’s performance. On a recent episode of The Night Cap, Shannon Sharpe, Johnny Manziel, and Chad Johnson analyzed the quarterback’s struggles.
Manziel questioned whether Manning had sufficient in-game experience to handle such a high-pressure scenario, while Sharpe expressed skepticism about labeling him a “generational” talent based on limited collegiate experience.
Analysts noted that Ohio State’s defense effectively exploited gaps in Texas’ execution, highlighting areas for Manning’s development.
Texas head coach Steve Sarkisian, however, emphasized patience and perspective. He acknowledged that the Longhorns fielded four new starters on the offensive line but noted that Manning generally had adequate time to throw.
“The growth throughout the game for Arch was really encouraging. We are going to be fine,” Sarkisian said. He described external expectations as unrealistic and urged observers to evaluate Manning’s performance over the course of the season rather than a single contest.
Manning took responsibility for the loss
“Ultimately, not good enough. Obviously, you don’t want to start off the season going 0-1. They’re a good team, but I thought we beat ourselves a lot. That starts with me. I’ve got to play better for us to win,” Manning added.
Looking ahead, Texas will face a series of less challenging opponents before its SEC opener at Florida on October 4.
Sarkisian emphasized that errors in execution, from inaccurate throws to inconsistent play-calling, are correctable and reiterated confidence in Manning’s potential. The coaching staff views development, patience, and incremental improvement as critical to both individual and team success.
While the loss will dominate early headlines, the Longhorns remain focused on growth and performance adjustments. Manning’s debut underscores the challenges facing highly touted freshmen quarterbacks but also highlights opportunities for refinement as the season progresses.
Read the full article here
