In a world like the Major League Baseball, some stars seem destined for the brightest lights and is their responsibility to match these expectations. For Paul Skenes, those lights are increasingly shining in the direction of the Bronx. While the Pittsburgh Pirates hold contractual control over their ace through 2029, a growing chorus of reports suggests the New York Yankees are preparing to go all-in to bring to Yankee Stadium well before he hits free agency.
What started as trade-deadline whispers in 2025 has transformed into a confirmed narrative of “when,” not “if.” This is why the Yankees are confident they can land the most dominant arm in baseball.
A big confidence gap in Pittsburgh
The roots of the Yankees’ pursuit lie in a revealing report from November 2025. This report claimed that Skenes, despite his public commitment to the Pirates, privately wants to play for the Yankees. The reason? A perceived lack of confidence that the Pirates organization can build a consistent winner during his tenure.
Skenes, to diminish the talks, was quick to downplay the rumors, insisting his goal is to win with the Pirates and help turn the franchise around. However, Thursday’s 2026 Opening Day disaster against the New York Mets did little to soothe those underlying fears. In a nightmare start at Citi Field, Skenes was betrayed by his defense, failing to escape the first inning after recording only two outs and surrendering five earned runs.
For a pitcher of his caliber, the sight of a 67.50 ERA, even for one day, is a jarring reminder of how quickly a lack of organizational support can undermine elite talent
The Livvy Dunne factor
Beyond the box scores, there is a distinct romantic element fueling the Yankees’ optimism for his arrival. Skenes’ girlfriend, social-media superstar and former gymnast Livvy Dunne, has already made New York City her home.
In late 2025, Dunne purchased a $2 million penthouse in the West Village after a highly publicized all-cash offer on Babe Ruth’s former apartment. Yankees insiders are reportedly “energized” by this connection, believing the allure of the “Big Apple” lifestyle and the ability to live in the same city as Dunne will eventually weigh heavier than any loyalty to the Steel City.
Will love play a big role in his decision or will he prioritize the support of an entire franchise?
Read the full article here
