Criticism was quick to come after the New York Yankees were eliminated in the American League Division Series by the Toronto Blue Jays. From their position as analysts at Fox Sports, Derek Jeter and Alex Rodriguez – two of the club’s greatest historical figures – had no qualms about questioning the current direction of the team.
Rodriguez, in particular, was blunt, calling the Yankees “one of the worst roster constructions I’ve ever seen”, a phrase that quickly ignited debate on social media and in the New York baseball community.
Jeter was more diplomatic, but no less critical. He said that manager Aaron Boone does not seem to have full control over tactical decisions. “I’m pretty sure Aaron is not the one ordering every move they make during the game,” he said live, hinting that the important decisions come directly from the management office.
Brian Cashman’s response
The statements did not go unnoticed by Brian Cashman, who has been the Yankees’ general manager and vice president for more than two decades. In an interview with WFAN radio, Cashman responded harshly to his former players and suggested that he even communicated with Jeter to clarify the situation.
“Clearly, they don’t know,” Cashman said. “I know DJ mentioned that he didn’t have any inside information, but he still said it. It’s the kind of comment that gets thrown around when there’s nothing else to say,” added the visibly upset executive.
Cashman also defended the independence of the coaching staff and downplayed the idea that the Yankees rely solely on analytics: “People think it’s all analytics, analytics, analytics… but none of that is accurate.”
Old wounds and new friction
The tension between Cashman and the club’s old guard is not new. Rodriguez, who signed a lucrative $275 million extension under Cashman’s management in 2008, ended his career mired in doping scandals.
Jeter, on the other hand, maintained a more institutional, albeit distant, relationship. After retiring in 2014, he became an owner and chairman of the Miami Marlins, a position he held until 2022. Since then, he has expressed his intention to stay close to baseball and the Yankees, although without a formal role.
A crisis that goes beyond the field
The elimination at the hands of Toronto, coupled with criticism from two historical icons, leaves the club in an uncomfortable position. The Yankees won 94 games and eliminated Boston in the wild-card series, but their lack of postseason clout again exposed structural flaws.
While rumors of changes in the front office grow, the controversy between Cashman, Jeter and A-Rod reflects something deeper: a fracture between the old guard and the new era of the Yankees.
Read the full article here
