With just over a month left in the Major League Baseball regular season, the New York Yankees are in a critical phase of their playoff push. No longer leading the American League East, they sit in third place but remain in contention for a Wild Card spot, closely trailing the Cleveland Guardians. As of today, August 19, 2025, the Yankees are positioned to potentially secure a postseason berth, but their opponent in the first round depends on their final standing. Here’s a look at who they could face if the playoffs started today, based on current standings and performance trends.
Current Playoff Picture
According to MLB.com standings as of August 16, 2025, the Yankees hold the third Wild Card spot in the American League with a 65-54 record, trailing the Toronto Blue Jays (68-51) and Boston Red Sox (61-56) in the division and Wild Card race. The Cleveland Guardians (61-56) are just behind them, making the race for the final Wild Card spot highly competitive.
If the playoffs began today, the Yankees would face the Houston Astros, the third-place team in the American League, in a best-of-three Wild Card series. The Astros, despite injuries, are a formidable opponent with a battle-tested core, though analysts note this matchup is “winnable” for the Yankees. However, the Yankees’ 3-7 record against the Astros this season suggests a challenging series.
Other Potential Opponents
If the Yankees improve their record and climb the Wild Card standings or even overtake the Blue Jays or Red Sox for a higher seed, their potential opponents could shift. Two teams that pose significant challenges are:
Toronto Blue Jays: The Yankees have struggled against Toronto, posting a 3-7 record this season. A Wild Card matchup against them would be tough, especially given Toronto’s strong 97.8% playoff odds and a relatively soft upcoming schedule.
Detroit Tigers: The Tigers have also been a difficult matchup for the Yankees, with a 1-2 record against them this season. The Tigers boast one of the easiest remaining schedules among contenders, giving them momentum in the Wild Card race.
Factors Influencing the Matchup
The Yankees‘ recent sweep of the St. Louis Cardinals, despite injuries to key players like Giancarlo Stanton and Aaron Judge, has provided a boost. Their bullpen, bolstered by trade deadline acquisitions like David Bednar and Jake Bird, is starting to perform as expected, which could be crucial in the postseason. Additionally, Jazz Chisholm Jr.’s emergence as a 20-20 player (20 home runs, 20 stolen bases) adds offensive firepower, potentially helping the Yankees improve their seeding.
However, their defensive errors, particularly from Anthony Volpe, and inconsistent play have raised concerns. Aaron Boone‘s decision to rest Volpe in favor of José Caballero against the Cardinals signals a potential shift to address defensive woes. The Yankees’ relatively easier remaining schedule compared to other contenders could help them secure a better Wild Card position or even challenge for the division lead.
Playoff Outlook
According to FanGraphs, the Yankees have an 85.2% chance of making the postseason, but their path is far from guaranteed. The American League is less competitive than the National League, giving the Yankees a slight edge over teams like the New York Mets, who face tougher opponents such as the Los Angeles Dodgers, Philadelphia Phillies, and Milwaukee Brewers. If the Yankees maintain their current Wild Card spot, they’ll likely face the Astros, but a climb in the standings could pit them against the Blue Jays or Tigers, both of whom have proven difficult this season.
Read the full article here
