Shedeur Sanders‘ emergence as a viable young quarterback option could complicate Aaron Rodgers‘ future with the Pittsburgh Steelers, as the franchise weighs patience against long-term stability at the position.
Pittsburgh has spent years searching for consistency under center, cycling through options since moving on from Ben Roethlisberger, and now faces another uncertain offseason while awaiting clarity on Rodgers‘ intentions.
The organization has maintained interest in Rodgers, yet progress has been limited, leaving the roster in a holding pattern.
Internally, questions continue to grow about how long the team can afford to wait without firm direction.
Without Rodgers locked in, Pittsburgh currently lists just two quarterbacks on the roster: Will Howard, the Steelers‘ 2025 sixthround pick, and veteran Mason Rudolph.
But neither has shown enough in limited opportunities to quiet doubts about their ability to carry an NFL franchise, especially one with Super Bowl aspirations.
“There doesn’t appear to be a Plan B, and incoming head coach Mike McCarthy will be desperate to get the band back together,” TalkSport US sports writer Jamie Gordon wrote, highlighting the perception that the Steelers are hoping history and familiarity might bridge the gap.
At the same time, some within league circles believe the Steelers may quietly evaluate Howard as a developmental option, even though the young quarterback has yet to take a regular-season snap at the professional level.
There, the Steelers could add a new name to their QB depth chart from April 23 to April 25, with the Round 1 picks on the Thursday, Round 2 and 3 picks on Friday and Rounds 4 through 7 on the Saturday.
Is the Shedeur Sanders method better than the Will Howard approach?
As uncertainty lingers, Shedeur Sanders has entered the conversation as a contrasting path, offering youth and upside compared to the short-term approach tied to Rodgers and the team’s current roster construction.
The Steelers previously passed on Sanders in the draft, opting instead to select Howard later, a decision that is now being revisited as Sanders gains experience elsewhere and begins to establish himself.
“To win in this NFL, you need a quarterback,” Haden said. “Right now, I like the Browns‘ quarterback a little bit better than the Steelers‘ quarterback.
“We’ve gotta see what Will Howard does. My quarterback, Shedeur, is a little bit better than [the Steelers] quarterback.”
Sanders‘ early career production has been modest but promising, appearing in multiple games and gaining valuable starting experience, which contrasts sharply with Howard‘s lack of professional snaps to this point.
Meanwhile, Rodgers‘ situation remains unresolved, and any further delay could increase pressure on head coach Mike McCarthy, whose arrival was partially tied to familiarity and expectations of stabilizing the position.
If Pittsburgh ultimately pivots toward a younger option like Sanders, it would signal a philosophical shift, prioritizing development over immediate contention, and potentially closing the door on Rodgers‘ anticipated return.
Read the full article here
