The Miami Dolphins approach the 2025 NFL season with uncertainty surrounding their quarterback position and broader concerns about the team’s competitive trajectory.
While head coach Mike McDaniel has earned praise for his offensive acumen, doubts remain about the stability of the franchise under owner Stephen Ross and the decision-making of general manager Chris Grier.
The most pressing issue lies under centre. Tua Tagovailoa enters his sixth season as Miami‘s starter on a lucrative contract but continues to draw scrutiny for both durability and performance.
His career has been marked by recurring injuries, and his decision-making has faced renewed criticism following recent joint practices with the Chicago Bears.
Reports from multiple outlets indicated Tagovailoa threw three interceptions during one session, including a red zone turnover to linebacker Tremaine Edmunds.
These struggles raise concerns about whether he can deliver consistent, mistake-free football over a full season.
Rookie Quinn Ewers brings long-term potential
Seventh-round draft pick Quinn Ewers could emerge as a storyline for Miami before the season concludes.
The former Texas quarterback was the final selection among 13 passers in the 2025 draft, taken after prospects such as Tyler Shough, Cam Miller, and Riley Leonard. Despite his draft position, Ewers brings significant collegiate experience.
He was instrumental in Texas’ resurgence under head coach Steve Sarkisian and is one of a select group of quarterbacks to win multiple College Football Playoff games.
Concerns about injuries and uneven production likely contributed to his fall in the draft. However, his arm strength, poise in high-pressure environments, and track record against elite competition suggest potential value for the Dolphins.
While he begins his professional career firmly behind Tagovailoa, a prolonged slump or health setback for the starter could accelerate his debut.
The Dolphins‘ immediate quarterback decision-making is influenced heavily by contractual realities. Tagovailoa‘s deal makes it financially challenging to move on from him quickly, even in the event of subpar performance.
Conversely, Ewers enters the league on a low-cost rookie contract, limiting the financial risk of giving him playing time if the season’s circumstances warrant.
McDaniel, meanwhile, faces pressure to produce results in 2025. Should playoff contention falter, the organisation could be compelled to evaluate Ewers in regular-season action to better understand his potential as a long-term starter.
This scenario would allow Miami to make more informed roster and draft decisions in 2026.
For Tagovailoa, the path to securing his position involves demonstrating improved decision-making, protecting the football, and avoiding extended absences due to injury.
The Dolphins‘ offensive rhythm depends heavily on his ability to manage games efficiently and sustain drives.
For Ewers, the focus in his rookie season will be preparation and incremental development. Remaining healthy, mastering the offensive system, and maximising opportunities in practice and preseason contests will be critical.
Any regular-season snaps would serve as an audition for a larger role in the future.
The Dolphins‘ success in 2025 will likely hinge on stability at quarterback. If Tagovailoa performs at a high level, Miami can remain competitive in the AFC.
If inconsistencies persist, the franchise may be forced to accelerate its evaluation of Ewers, potentially signalling the beginning of a new era at the position.
Read the full article here
