Colin Cowherd has ignited controversy in his latest commentary when he asserted that the Kansas City Chiefs’ success can be attributed to Patrick Mahomes, but not head coach Andy Reid.
The pair have won three Super Bowls together and narrowly missed out on a three-peat after losing to the Eagles in Super Bowl LIX.
But on his show The Herd, Cowherd theorized that Mahomes has carried the Chiefs – and Reid – to new heights, rather than the other way around: “As great as Andy Reid is, he only started hoisting trophies when he got Patrick Mahomes,” he said.
His provocative perspective frames the Chiefs’ success not as a product of their legendary coach but as a direct byproduct of acquiring the once-in-a-generation quarterback.
Cowherd’s analysis echoes a growing sentiment: Mahomes is unequivocally the key ingredient in Kansas City’s accomplishments.
Since taking over as starting quarterback in 2018, Mahomes has transformed the franchise, leading them to multiple Super Bowl titles and redefining what elite quarterback play means. It’s a claim that challenges traditional narratives crediting Reid as the architect.turn0search0
A bold reframing of Mahomes-Reid dynamic
While Reid’s coaching resume is stellar – turning around the Chiefs and implementing inventive schemes – Cowherd’s view reframes the conversation. He suggests that the franchise’s championship era truly began with Mahomes’ arrival, not just Reid’s guidance. In essence, Mahomes elevated Reid.
This doesn’t diminish Reid’s role outright: he nurtured Mahomes behind veteran quarterback Alex Smith, allowing the young star to learn before unleashing his talents. Veteran lineman Joe Thuney emphasized Mahomes’ maturity and preparation – traits Reid helped instill.
By contrast, critics argue Reid’s success plateaued during his time with the Eagles, only ramping up when paired with Mahomes.
Yet analysts and former players see this as a glowing endorsement of the Chiefs’ synergy. As Chiefs offensive lineman Thuney observed, Mahomes and Reid “get the job done” through film study, leadership, and relentless work ethic.
Cowherd’s contention highlights a broader debate: which matters more – the quarterback’s brilliance or the coaching system enabling it? For the Chiefs, it’s both. The decision to elevate Mahomes was bold; Reid’s trust in him was decisive. But once unleashed, Mahomes transformed Kansas City from playoff regulars to a dynasty.
Despite losing Super Bowl LIX to Philadelphia, Mahomes continues to set statistical landmarks-with passer ratings consistently above 92.6, never throwing fewer than 3,900 passing yards, and rarely dipping into low turnover margins.
Meanwhile, Reid continues to innovate through game planning and red zone creativity-recently revisiting “Corn Dog” misdirection plays that helped win Super Bowl LVII.
Mahomes comes up trumps when it matters
Mahomes’ consistency and clutch performance in high-pressure moments-with Belichick-style leadership and veteran poise-suggests his value transcends even Reid’s system. Still, Reid’s role in building the culture and schematics that allow sustained excellence cannot be dismissed.
As the Chiefs aim to win a third Super Bowl in four years, the dynamic between quarterback and coach remains central. Analysts note the team’s formula: Mahomes’ elite instincts and Reid’s tactical flexibility. Their combined leadership, along with Stephen Spagnuolo’s dominant defense, forms an organizational DNA built for championships.
Whether Cowherd’s view is viewed as an insult to Reid or an overdue recognition of Mahomes, it underscores one truth: the Chiefs’ modern glory is intricately tied to Mahomes executing nightly.
Kansas City’s success story is not a binary. It’s a fusion: Mahomes’ transcendent quarterbacking lifted Reid’s system-and Reid’s trust unlocked Mahomes’ greatness. Cowherd may be provoking debate-but he’s also raising a valid point: in the story of the Chiefs’ dynasty, Mahomes is undeniably the defining chapter.
Read the full article here
