The Pittsburgh Steelers find themselves at a crossroads this offseason, as they’re wrestling with one of the most consequential decisions in recent franchise history: the retirement of head coach Mike Tomlin.
Following Tomlin‘s departure, the Steelers hired former Green Bay Packers and Dallas Cowboys coach Mike McCarthy to lead the team – a move that has immediately sparked debate across NFL circles.
Central to the controversy is whether Pittsburgh should reunite McCarthy with veteran quarterback Aaron Rodgers, a pairing that some insiders now warn could backfire dramatically.
Analyst Benjamin Solak made no effort to sugarcoat his skepticism, arguing that the reunion “would be an absolutely horrible decision” for a franchise that has long prided itself on stability and identity.
Last season, Rodgers delivered a mixed performance in Pittsburgh. According to the PFSN NFL QB Impact Metric, he ranked 29th among qualifying quarterbacks in 2025, and his postseason showing was widely criticized as underwhelming.
Solak emphasized that, despite the familiarity between quarterback and coach, the charted history doesn’t guarantee future success.
“There’s no, no, no reason to do it again,” Solak said during an appearance on the “Up & Adams Show.” “Rodgers, at this point in his career, with his playstyle and athletic limitations, it’s really hard for him to be a successful QB.”
Solak reiterated his bleak outlook with a blunt assertion about what would happen if the Steelers pursued the reunion. “It will not go well… and boring,” he added.
Concerns about direction, culture, and future planning
Solak didn’t limit his criticism to the potential quarterback-coach pairing; he also questioned the overall organizational strategy.
With Tomlin‘s departure, many felt the Steelers had a rare opportunity to reset the franchise, infusing new energy and modern approaches into the roster and coaching structure.
Instead, Solak argued, Pittsburgh doubled down on familiar names rather than embracing a transformative path.
“When Tomlin stepped down, the Steelers had a real opportunity to hit a reset button… and try to modernize,” he said. “And they went the completely other direction. And that is a terrible shame.”
For decades, the Steelers have been synonymous with consistency – from sustained success under long-tenured head coaches to a steadfast commitment to scouting and player development that has set the standard across the league.
As Solak noted, reverting to a model centered on veteran pedigree rather than forward-looking talent raises legitimate questions about where the franchise is headed.
Who will start under center for the Steelers in the 2026 NFL season?
Rodgers, who led the team to a 10-7 record and an AFC North title in 2025, threw for 3,322 yards with 24 touchdowns and seven interceptions, statistics that reflect more steadiness than superstar dominance.
Yet despite that production, his limitations at age 42 – and particularly his playoff struggles – have tempered enthusiasm about his long-term viability as Pittsburgh‘s answer under center.
McCarthy‘s hiring itself has been described by some as a nod to tradition rather than innovation. With a Super Bowl victory and an extensive coaching resume, McCarthy undoubtedly brings experience.
He also has a deep history with Rodgers, having coached him for more than a decade during their tenure in Green Bay, including a championship run in the 2010 playoffs.
The quarterback room also features younger options such as Will Howard and veteran Mason Rudolph, neither of whom has consistently proven capable of leading a playoff-caliber squad on their own.
Consequently, the allure of Rodgers, who’s as experienced and proven as any QB in the NFL, is understandable. Yet the underlying concern, as expressed by Solak, is that short-term stability could come at the expense of long-term growth.
Read the full article here
