Naomi Osaka’s return to top-tier tennis has been anything but smooth. Despite clinching a WTA 125 title earlier this month, the former World No. 1 has struggled at major tournaments in 2025 and continued her miserable run at Roland-Garros.
After early exits in Madrid and Rome, Osaka’s French Open campaign ended in heartbreak with a first-round loss to Spain’s Paula Badosa in three sets: 6-7(1), 6-1, 6-4.
The defeat marked her third first-round loss this season and reignited fan concerns about her performance trajectory. But it wasn’t just the loss that made headlines – it was Osaka’s raw post-match comments that triggered a wave of online reactions.
“I hate disappointing people,” she admitted. “Even with Patrick [Mouratoglou], I was thinking just now that he goes from working with like the greatest player ever to like… what the f**k this is.”
The statement, referencing her coach Patrick Mouratoglou – best known for guiding Serena Williams during the latter half of her career – sparked debate among fans and critics alike. Many interpreted it as a stark self-comparison to Williams, a move some viewed as counterproductive.
Fan Reactions range from criticism to comparison
Osaka’s remarks added fuel to existing frustrations among fans, some of whom have accused her of being preoccupied with living up to Williams’ legacy.
“She’s been copying Serena for years – this comparison is doing more harm than good,” one user posted on Twitter.
Others took issue with Osaka’s on-court presentation and off-court focus, suggesting that her fashion-forward appearances were distracting from her tennis.
“I think she even wants to dress like her idol,” one fan quipped.
“She needs to retire at this point.”
These reactions reflect a broader sentiment that Osaka is facing an identity crisis on tour-torn between honoring her idol and carving her own path.
While Osaka bore the brunt of criticism, Mouratoglou was not spared. Fans questioned his influence and record with players other than Williams.
“He keeps name-dropping Serena, but let’s be honest – he hasn’t had success with anyone else. He’s built more of a brand than a legacy,” one comment read.
The implication: Osaka may not benefit from a coach still living in the shadow of his past accomplishments.
This isn’t the first time Osaka has drawn comparisons to Serena Williams. After defeating Williams in the 2018 U.S. Open final to claim her maiden Grand Slam, Osaka was frequently hailed as her successor. But while she has four Grand Slam titles to her name, her form in recent years has been inconsistent – especially since her return from maternity leave.
Critics argue that comparisons to one of the greatest players of all time are not only unfair but psychologically taxing.
“Putting herself next to Serena only increases the pressure,” explained another fan.
“And you can see it’s weighing her down.”
Read the full article here
