The Indianapolis Colts are in the eye of the storm following the recent injury of quarterback Anthony Richardson, who suffered inflammation in the AC joint of his right shoulder-the same injury that led him to undergo surgery in 2023. According to reports, Richardson will be out at least until training camp, leaving Daniel Jones as the starting quarterback during minicamp practices.
But what’s really stirring up buzz on social media and among analysts is the theory that the Colts may be planning a strategic “tanking” to secure a high pick in the 2026 draft-with the name Arch Manning, the young Texas prodigy, as the ultimate target.
The idea that the Colts might let Daniel Jones-a quarterback with a history of ups and downs-lead a mediocre season isn’t far-fetched. Jones, who signed a one-year, $14 million deal, has yet to prove he’s an elite NFL quarterback in his six seasons in the league. His time with the Giants showed flashes, particularly in 2022, but his inconsistency and tendency to make mistakes have made him an easy target for criticism.
If the Colts, as some suggest on X, allow Jones to have a lackluster season, they could end up in position for a top draft pick-and Arch Manning, nephew of Peyton and Eli, is the name gaining traction.
How a bad season for Jones could change everything
Manning, quarterback for the Texas Longhorns, is seen as a generational talent. His last name carries a mystique that excites Indianapolis fans-especially since Peyton Manning is a Colts legend. Arch has shown off a strong arm, high football IQ, and a level of maturity that sets him apart, though he still needs to refine parts of his game.
A high pick in the 2026 draft could open the door for the Colts to restart their quarterback project-especially if Richardson fails to solidify himself after recurring injuries and a disappointing 47.7% completion rate in 2024.
Although “tanking” is a controversial topic, it wouldn’t be the first time an NFL team plays its cards with the future in mind. The Colts, with a talented roster that includes Jonathan Taylor and wide receivers like Michael Pittman Jr., could afford a transitional year if the reward is someone like Manning.
For now, Daniel Jones has the opportunity to prove he deserves the starting job. But if the rumors are true, the Colts might already be dreaming of a new Manning leading their offense in 2026.
Read the full article here
