The Pro Football Hall of Fame in Canton is under unprecedented scrutiny. The recent exclusion of Bill Belichick has not only left analysts stunned, but has also prompted even his former rivals to speak out in protest, arguing that factors beyond on-field merit appear to be influencing the decision.
One of the most forceful reactions came from Eli Manning, the man who denied him two Super Bowls, who did not hesitate to describe the outcome as something that defies all sporting logic.
Manning, who for the second consecutive year remained among the 15 finalists without earning induction, admitted that his own disappointment took a back seat upon learning the fate of the former Patriots strategist. “Bill Belichick not making the Hall of Fame is pretty shocking,” he declared, joining other voices who cannot believe that one of the most successful head coaches is not on the list.
For the former New York Giants quarterback, Belichick’s credentials are unquestionable: “You have one of – if not maybe the greatest coach of all time – and what he built there in New England… was incredible.”
Manning was emphatic in closing his stance: “I can’t imagine a more deserving coach to make it in the Hall of Fame than him.”
A dynasty ignored: The discontent among the protagonists
Manning’s indignation is only the tip of the iceberg of a widespread sentiment across the league. Belichick’s exclusion, combined with the repeated rejections of Patriots owner Robert Kraft, has fueled a narrative of a “blockade” by the selection committee against the Foxborough organization.
Several NFL legends have argued that the Hall of Fame is losing credibility by overlooking the architects of the most dominant dynasty of the modern era. The criticism centers on the following points:
- The Robert Kraft factor: Multiple former players and league historians consider it “inexcusable” that Kraft has not been inducted, given his fundamental role in the NFL’s economic growth and sustained success.
- Editorial revenge: Some analysts and former members of the New England Patriots suggest that the voting committee (composed primarily of journalists) may be settling personal scores due to the often tense and guarded relationship Belichick maintained with the media during his 24 years in New England.
This year’s omission leaves one pressing question: if six Vince Lombardi Trophy titles and the unanimous respect of rivals like Eli Manning are not enough to enter Canton, then what is?
Read the full article here
