When Indianapolis Colts owner Jim Irsay died in May of 2025, the one question that rose immediately was who would continue his legacy. His oldest daughter, Carlie Irsay-Gordon.
Already an institution within the group, Carlie was the new principal owner and CEO of the team. But with fame comes a new level of intrigue, wondering how much money does she have, and what is her ownership stake in the Colts?
A billionaire by inheritance
According to ‘Finance Monthly’, The Indianapolis Colts sit now at a $5.9 billion value. Divided among Carlie and her sisters, Casey Foyt and Kalen Jackson, with a share split equally, that would leave her about $1.9 billion.
While those figures are headline news, the majority of Carlie’s wealth is closely aligned with the worth of the team and not liquid assets. Her wealth is therefore enormous on paper but highly reliant on the Colts franchise and their performance in the sports long run.
A lifetime in the organization
Carlie’s path to ownership did not occur overnight. She started out working as a ticket officer and marketing employee for the Colts and ended up getting into management positions. She was promoted to vice president in 2008 and became a vice chair of the franchise in 2012, joining her sisters.
Those first few years of job training provided the foundation for her promotion in 2025, when her father’s death set off the family’s succession plan. Now Carlie is not just the team’s representative to the NFL owners’ meetings but the decision-maker who charts the Colts’ financial and strategic path.
Duties that go beyond economy
Carlie’s net worth of an estimated $1.9 billion has placed her among the wealthiest women in sports. However, with the role of principal owner comes authority that reaches far beyond dollars and cents. She represents the Colts at league negotiations, decides on player and coaching personnel moves, and oversees the team’s community relations initiatives, serving as a core value of the Irsay family.
Her sisters are similarly actively engaged. Casey Foyt is an executive vice president, while Kalen Jackson oversees brand activity as well as the Colts’ philanthropic foundation. All together, the Irsay daughters come together to provide the team’s stability and advancement.
Potential challenges ahead
In spite of the impressive valuations, ownership is not free from troubles at all. NFL teams are illiquid but high-value assets. Estate taxes, operating costs, and on-field performance can all affect how much of that perceived wealth is on hand.
There is the added burden of staying ahead in a league that feeds off competitive equilibrium. The on-field success of the Colts will directly translate to maintaining and possibly increasing the Irsay family fortune.
Women in power
Carlie Irsay-Gordon’s elevation is indicative of a wider trend among American team ownership. One of a few but increasingly sizable group of women to helm major league teams, her rise to the top office shows that a shift is underway in the NFL.
With a conservatively estimated net worth of almost $2 billion, she is the epitome of inheritance’s privilege and responsibility. Yet her years with the Colts dynasty imply that she is an heir to something greater than riches, as she is a keeper of a franchise that is indelibly stitched into the fabric of Indianapolis.
Read the full article here
