The Kansas City Chiefs entered Week 16 already eliminated from playoff contention, yet few anticipated the level of underperformance that unfolded in a 26-9 loss to the Tennessee Titans, a team that had won only twice all season.
The defeat has intensified scrutiny on Andy Reid’s play calling and leadership, as fans and analysts question whether his strategies remain effective during what has been a challenging season.
Kansas City’s offensive struggles were glaring. The team gained just 133 yards on 43 plays, averaging only 3.09 yards per snap, well below their season average of roughly 4.2 yards.
Their third-down efficiency was abysmal, converting only one of nine opportunities, while Chris Oladokun, stepping in as the third-choice quarterback, was sacked four times. The loss of both Patrick Mahomes and backup Gardner Minshew to knee injuries left Kansas City with limited options, but it also exposed issues with offensive design that predated injuries.
A key problem was the running game. Early drives demonstrated poorly executed running angles that immediately closed off scoring opportunities, revealing flaws in play design rather than isolated mistakes. Critics have highlighted Reid and offensive coordinator Matt Nagy’s tendency to rely on veteran players rather than give younger talent meaningful reps.
Players such as Jalen Royals and Brashard Smith saw limited action, prompting questions about why the Chiefs prioritized familiarity over development during a season that was already out of reach.
Chiefs’ season woes and Reid’s decision
Despite growing criticism, Reid has dismissed retirement speculation. The 67-year-old head coach confirmed he intends to return in 2026, emphasizing that the team will use the offseason to regroup and improve.
While his commitment to continuity is clear, the decision has done little to quell debate over whether his conservative play calling contributed to the team’s struggles.
In addition to injuries, critics argue that poor execution and conservative offensive decisions have amplified the Chiefs’ difficulties. With Mahomes still recovering from ACL surgery and Minshew awaiting MRI results, the spotlight on Reid has intensified, focusing not just on individual game decisions but also on the long-term direction of the franchise.
Analysts and fans alike are questioning whether a fresh approach might be necessary to adapt to an evolving league and maximize the team’s remaining talent.
Reid‘s choice to maintain familiar personnel and strategies, even in a lost season, has sparked talks about the balance between experience and experimentation in the NFL.
While the coach’s legacy includes numerous playoff runs and a Super Bowl victory, the 2025 campaign has turned a routine discussion about injuries into a broader debate over the future of one of the league’s most iconic leaders.
Read the full article here
