For Aaron Boone, managing the New York Yankees has been a study in consistency-and frustration. Over the past decade, he has avoided losing seasons, kept the team competitive, and guided them to seven postseasons.
Yet, the ultimate prize, a World Series title, has remained just out of reach, drawing criticism from fans, analysts, and even veteran sportswriters.
Legendary sportswriter Neil Best put Boone‘s situation into perspective on the Locked on Yankees podcast. “I guess [Aaron Boone]’s a lot like Mike Tomlin because he always wins, but he doesn’t win the big one,” Best said.
“The guy wins; he has more resources than most managers, but it really, really would help to win a championship. Like Tomlin, he never has a losing record. Boone has been very successful, but you’re supposed to win a championship.”
Boone‘s career mirrors the paradox of winning without ultimate success. Mike Tomlin, the longtime coach of the Pittsburgh Steelers, has a 193-114-2 regular-season record, but just an 8-12 postseason mark after his Super Bowl XLIII win in 2008.
Boone, meanwhile, holds a 697-497 record in Major League Baseball, leading the Yankees to seven playoff appearances with a single World Series showing in 2024.
Despite the team’s vast resources, an $8.2 billion valuation and $728 million in revenue, according to Forbes, Boone has struggled to assemble a roster capable of reaching the pinnacle.
Last season exposed cracks in the Yankees’ lineup, including injuries to key pitchers Carlos Rodon and Clarke Schmidt, underperformance from hitters like Jasson Dominguez and Devin Williams, and a rotating cast at third base featuring DJ LeMahieu, Oswaldo Cabrera, and Oswald Peraza. These weaknesses contributed to the team’s ALDS exit at the hands of the Toronto Blue Jays.
Boone‘s optimism, once considered an asset, has also drawn scrutiny. Neil Best noted, “As far as with the media, which again is what I care more about, a lot of the beat writers get a little tired of his answers sometimes, and he’s too positive.”
After a Game 2 Subway Series loss, Boone told reporters, “It was a really great baseball game. It really was,” highlighting the kind of relentless positivity that frustrates some fans expecting blunt assessments.
Aaron Boone leans on Anthony Volpe for resurgence
Looking ahead, Boone is placing considerable faith in 24-year-old shortstop Anthony Volpe, who is returning from a partially torn labrum in his left shoulder. Despite last season’s struggles, most notably a 10-game stretch in August with just one hit in 33 plate appearances, Boone remains confident in Volpe‘s potential.
“I still think Anthony’s gonna be a frontline shortstop in this league,” Boone said.
“Everyone’s path isn’t linear. We always want it to be, and that can be tough, especially in New York, where you’re kind of finding your way.”
Volpe‘s flashes of promise include his Opening Day solo home run off a 95.4 mph fastball, boasting a 103.8 mph exit velocity, and a 2025 season total of 19 home runs and 72 RBIs across 153 games.
He will resume his role in the Yankees’ infield alongside Amed Rosario, Oswaldo Cabrera, and Jose Caballero, forming the core that Boone hopes can push the team toward its next championship run.
With returning pitchers Gerrit Cole, Carlos Rodon, and Clarke Schmidt expected to rejoin the rotation, albeit recovering from injuries, and new additions like Ryan Weathers, Boone faces a high-stakes season.
The question remains: can his unwavering faith in players like Volpe finally end the Yankees’ championship drought, or will another season of close calls and playoff heartbreak await?
Read the full article here
