Jeff McNeil’s name has been at the center of conversations among New York Mets fans and analysts
After an inconsistent season, marked by injuries and a drop in his offensive production, doubts arise as to whether the team should consider moving him on in the next transfer window. At 33 years of age, McNeil is still a versatile player, but is it enough to justify keeping him?
Declining performance
McNeil finished the 2025 season with a batting average below .250, far from his best years, where he was above .300. Although he is still a reliable defender at second base and in the outfield, his offensive impact has diminished, affecting the team’s overall production.
Age and market value
At 33 years old, McNeil is at a stage where many players begin to lose speed and consistency. His current contract still represents a significant financial commitment for the Mets, which could limit the team’s financial flexibility in search of reinforcements. Some experts suggest that this could be the ideal time to explore a trade that benefits both parties.
Internal and external alternatives
The Mets have young talent such as Ronny Mauricio and Brett Baty, who could take on more prominent roles in the infield. In addition, the free agent market offers interesting options to strengthen second base with younger players or with more consistent offensive profiles.
The emotional factor
McNeil has been a key part of the Mets clubhouse, and his departure could affect the team’s chemistry. His leadership and experience are intangible assets that are not always reflected in statistics. For many fans, letting him go would be closing an important chapter in the club’s recent history.
Key decision for the future
The Mets management faces a complex decision: to go for renewal and look for new pieces, or to trust that McNeil can recover his level and continue to contribute. With the 2026 season on the horizon, the player’s future will be one of the most closely followed topics in Queens.
Read the full article here
