The 2025 season has been one of the most difficult for Anthony Volpe since his arrival in Major League Baseball, with offensive numbers below expectations, an OPS of just .665 and the worst OBP in the American League at .269, which has caused the player to lose prominence in the Yankees’ lineup. Defensively, the situation is no better, only Elly De La Cruz has committed more errors, which still raises doubts about his reliability as a starting shortstop.
This decline has begun to wear the organization thin, according to ESPN reports, several rival executives believe the Yankees could part ways with Volpe during the offseason. What seemed like a safe bet for the future now looks like a change that could leave the Bronx sooner than expected.
Who would replace Volpe? Yankees value Jose Caballero and other options
With the postseason just around the corner and the need for immediate adjustments, the Yankees are already exploring new alternatives, one of which is Jose Caballero, who could take over the shortstop role if Volpe is sent to the bench or finally transferred. Caballero offers a more solid defensive profile, something the team values especially at this key time of the season.
However, the outlook in the shortstop market is not encouraging, figures such as Bo Bichette could be available, but his defense generates as many doubts as Volpe’s. The dilemma for the front office is whether they should risk selling low on a former star prospect or continue to bet on his development despite his stumbles.
Are the Yankees parting ways with Anthony Volpe? Here’s what we know
Beyond performance, Volpe’s contractual situation also comes into play, as he will be arbitration eligible after the season, which could increase his salary in 2026 without offering the Yankees any long-term guarantee. This opens the door to a possible change of scenery for the player, especially if the team looks to revamp its roster ahead of a new championship window.
Volpe, just 24 years old, is still young and has room to grow, but in a franchise like the Yankees, patience is not eternal. While there are no official confirmations yet, his name will be on the table when the World Series ends and any decision about his future could set the course for the team in the coming years.
Read the full article here
