The New York Yankees are walking a razor’s edge in August, their postseason hopes hanging in the balance while injuries and inconsistency test every part of the roster.
The latest blow came when first baseman Paul Goldschmidt, brought in to provide veteran stability and power, suffered a knee sprain that sidelined him just as the team returned to St. Louis.
His return to Busch Stadium was supposed to be emotional. Instead, he was limited to a late-game cameo, leaving the Yankees with yet another critical hole.
“I knew we were coming here, and I would love to play,” Goldschmidt admitted. “But if it was going to be an injury risk, I understand the big picture. I didn’t want to push it.”
That “big picture” now falls squarely on manager Aaron Boone, who must decide whether to stick with internal options or convince general manager Brian Cashman to make a $10.3 million gamble that could shift the direction of the season.
The Yankees’ options are limited and each comes with risk. Cody Bellinger could shift to first, but that weakens the outfield.
Ben Rice offers promise, though the move would further complicate things with Austin Wells already struggling at catcher. That leaves the newly available Nathaniel Lowe as a possible stopgap.
Lowe’s 2025 numbers (.216/.292/.373, 16 home runs) are discouraging, but his past production – including a Silver Slugger award – makes him a potential buy-low candidate.
For Boone, the question is whether a struggling veteran can rediscover form in New York’s lineup. Rival teams, including the Mets, are also reportedly interested, adding urgency to the Yankees’ decision.
At the trade deadline, fans expected Cashman to make a splash to address weaknesses, especially in the bullpen. Instead, the lack of movement has drawn sharp criticism, leaving Boone to balance a roster patched together with short-term solutions.
Boone and Cashman under the spotlight
The Yankees’ recent stumbles have intensified scrutiny on Boone’s leadership style.
Critics accuse him of protecting players too much, pointing to his defense of struggling relievers like Devin Williams. Yet Cashman continues to publicly back his manager.
“The best he can,” Cashman told the New York Post when asked about Boone’s handling of the pressure.
“I’ve told him many times how he does the pre- and postgame press conferences and navigates that on a daily basis, that’s not easy.
“He’s stayed level-headed and even-keeled. He knows how tough this sport is.”
Boone’s calm approach divides the fanbase. Some see it as steadying influence, others as a sign of complacency. But the Yankees’ front office appears committed to riding out the turbulence with him.
Read the full article here
