The New York Knicks’ loss to the Indiana Pacers in the NBA playoffs sent shockwaves through the organization. Every level of the franchise was forced into a deep self-examination to determine what went wrong. Ultimately, the one who paid the price was head coach Tom Thibodeau.
Thibodeau joined the Knicks in 2020 under team president Leon Rose, who had a long-standing relationship with him, along with vice president William Wesley, dating back to their time at the talent agency CAA.
Rose convinced owner Jim Dolan that Thibodeau was the right man for the job, banking on his reputation as a hard-nosed, disciplined coach who valued effort above all else. While this approach initially brought success, it ultimately contributed to his downfall.
Why did the Knicks fire Thibodeau?
The loss to the Pacers-an opponent many believed the Knicks should have beaten-was merely the final straw. Thibodeau’s departure had been brewing for months, largely due to his rigid coaching style, which even drew public criticism from his players.
Despite back-to-back seasons with 50+ wins, insiders say the players, coaching staff, and front office had lost faith in Thibodeau’s ability to lead them to the Finals. Criticism ranged from his inflexible playbook to his questionable playoff decisions.
The series against Indiana was a microcosm of the Knicks’ season-long struggles. Thibodeau is known for sticking to a strategy and refusing to adjust, often overplaying his starters while leaving a talented bench waiting for opportunities that never came.
The 2:50 collapse that sealed his fate
Had the Knicks defeated the Pacers and reached the NBA Finals, all of Thibodeau’s shortcomings might have been overlooked. However, the Game 1 meltdown-where the team squandered a 14-point lead in the final 2:50-set the tone for the series and ultimately marked the end of Thibodeau’s tenure in New York.
Following a series of meetings with players and coaching staff, Rose and Dolan made the difficult but necessary decision to part ways with Thibodeau. “Our organization is singularly focused on winning a championship for our fans,” Rose stated in the announcement.
The message was clear: Thibodeau was no longer the right man for the job. Now, the Knicks must rebuild, leveraging their existing foundation while seeking new leadership capable of breaking through the Conference Finals barrier for the first time in 25 years.
Read the full article here
