Shedeur Sanders, the Colorado Buffaloes‘ golden arm, is heading into the 2025 NFL Draft with sky-high buzz-but not everyone’s buying the hype. Just weeks before the April 24 draft kicks off in Green Bay, a veteran NFL scout unloaded a brutal take on the 22-year-old QB, sending shockwaves through the football world.
Athlon Sports dropped the scoop on March 28, quoting the scout who didn’t mince words: “He’s overrated-great stats, sure, but he’s a product of hype more than substance.” That’s a punch for a guy who’s been pegged as a top-10 lock.
Sanders lit up 2024 with 4,134 passing yards, 37 touchdowns, and a nation-leading 74.2% completion rate, per ESPN stats, steering Colorado to a 9-4 finish. His pocket poise and laser accuracy earned raves-ESPN’s Matt Miller called him “Jared Goff 2.0” for his pinpoint throws-but this scout’s not impressed.
“He’s got talent, no doubt, but he folds when the pocket gets messy,” the unnamed evaluator told Athlon Sports. “Too many sacks, too much panic-NFL defenses will eat him alive.” With 52 sacks taken last season, thanks to a shaky Buffs O-line, it’s a critique that’s got some teeth.
NFL Scout tears into Shedeur before 2025 Draft chaos
The scout’s jab isn’t solo-posts on X show a split vibe. One fan fired back, “Shedeur’s a baller, stats don’t lie-this scout’s just salty,” while another nodded, “He’s gotta prove he’s more than a clean-pocket QB.” Sanders’ minus-87 rushing yards in 2024 don’t scream mobility, and that’s fuel for doubters. Still, his 151.7 QB rating and Big 12 Offensive Player of the Year nod, per BuffsBeat, keep his stock sizzling-Mel Kiper Jr. ranked him No. 5 overall on March 18.
What’s the beef really about? “He’s got the arm, but not the grit,” the scout added, questioning Sanders’ toughness under fire compared to peers like Miami’s Cam Ward. It’s a stark flip from another scout’s take via The Buffalo News, who gushed, “He’ll start Day 1-nothing fazes him.” That variance is pure draft chaos-teams like the Giants or Raiders, hunting a QB savior, might see a diamond or a dud.
Sanders, son of NFL legend Deion, isn’t sweating it-at least not publicly. “I just play my game,” he told reporters after a December bowl win. With the draft clock ticking, this scout’s rip is lighting a fire under an already wild storyline.
Read the full article here
