The Los Angeles Lakers’ disappointing first-round playoff loss to the Minnesota Timberwolves has sparked intense criticism, with much of the scrutiny falling on head coach JJ Redick. Despite strong performances from LeBron James, Luka Doncic, and Rui Hachimura, the Lakers failed to overcome the Timberwolves, losing 96-103 in Game 5, and prompting a wave of debate about coaching decisions and team strategy.
Among the loudest voices critiquing Redick’s approach was Skip Bayless, who took to X to call Redick “supremely arrogantly stubborn” for refusing to play Jaxson Hayes in the elimination game. Hayes, a 6-foot-11 center, was left on the bench despite Rudy Gobert’s dominance in the Paint, a decision Bayless and many others viewed as costly in a high-stakes moment.
Bayless wasn’t alone in questioning Redick’s coaching. Throughout the playoff series, Redick’s game management, particularly his refusal to adjust lineups, drew sharp criticism. His decision in Game 4 to keep all his starters on the court for the entire second half without a substitution was widely debated. Though he altered his approach in Game 5, it was too little, too late.
Magic Johnson and Brian Windhorst weigh in
Lakers legend Magic Johnson also pointed out key flaws in the team’s performance, adding to the mounting questions about Redick’s leadership. Meanwhile, ESPN analyst Brian Windhorst relayed a story from Reggie Miller, who reportedly had to calm Redick down before Game 5, describing his behavior as “childish”.
Redick’s struggles in the postseason have fueled conversations about his readiness for an NBA coaching role. As a first-year head coach, Redick was under immense pressure to deliver results, particularly after the Lakers traded Anthony Davis to Dallas for Luka Doncic, a move that reshaped the team’s roster composition.
With the Lakers now in offseason mode, the organization faces pressing questions, most notably LeBron James’ future. At 40 years old, James has yet to confirm whether he will return for another season, leaving the team’s direction uncertain.
Redick, despite the criticism, still holds the trust of Lakers GM Rob Pelinka, who defended both the Doni trade and the coaching hire. But with fan frustrations mounting, the Lakers will need to address their roster construction, defensive weaknesses, and leadership dynamics if they hope to return to championship contention.
Read the full article here
