The New York Giants’ 2025 season has been a turbulent one, and recent performances have fueled debate over the development of rookie quarterback Jaxson Dart.
Following a narrow 16-13 loss to the Minnesota Vikings on Sunday, questions have emerged about whether Dart, the 25th overall pick, is regressing as he navigates the challenges of his first NFL campaign. The game proved difficult for the young quarterback, who threw for just 33 yards, recorded an interception, and was sacked five times.
Completing slightly over 50% of his passes and failing to reach the end zone for the first time this season, Dart appeared unsettled in the Giants’ offense, drawing concern from fans and analysts alike.
Despite the criticism, interim head coach Mike Kafka pushed back against the notion that Dart is regressing. Kafka stressed that the rookie’s progression remains intact and pointed to circumstances outside Dart‘s control that contributed to the struggles.
“I feel great about our gameplan,” Kafka said, highlighting the difference between the quarterback’s potential and the situational challenges he faced on the field.
Dart’s early season performances offer important context. The quarterback made a splash in Week 4 by outdueling Chargers star Justin Herbert, leading the Giants to a hard-fought victory that energized the team. That momentum continued with a Thursday Night Football win against division rival Philadelphia Eagles, giving fans hope that Dart could stabilize the Giants’ offense.
However, that initial optimism has faded as the team has dropped nine consecutive games, creating mounting pressure on the rookie quarterback to find consistency under challenging circumstances.
Giants’ offensive struggles add to Dart’s challenges
Many of Dart‘s difficulties stem from more than just his individual performance. Key injuries along the offensive line left him vulnerable, including the loss of left tackle Andrew Thomas, center John Michael Schmitz, and starting left guard Jon Runyan.
These setbacks forced Dart into a reactive mode, scrambling to salvage plays under heavy pressure. Adding to the challenge, Dart has spent most of his rookie season without the Giants’ top receiving weapons, Malik Nabers and Cam Skattebo, limiting his options in the passing game and further testing his adaptability.
While Dart certainly carries some responsibility for the Vikings loss, Kafka‘s comments underscore the importance of context. The rookie’s journey is far from linear, and his development is being shaped by factors well beyond his control.
With the coaching staff maintaining confidence in Dart‘s abilities, the focus now is on stabilizing the roster, protecting the quarterback, and providing him the tools to succeed. If the Giants can address these issues, Dart‘s potential could shine through.
Read the full article here
