On September 5, Caitlin Clark, the electrifying star of the Indiana Fever and the 2024 WNBA Rookie of the Year, delivered heartbreaking news to fans: she will not return for the remainder of the 2025 season. Limited to just 13 games due to a series of injuries-including a left quadriceps sprain, left and right groin injuries, and a bone bruise in her left ankle-Clark shared her frustration in a candid social media post:
“I was hoping to share a better update, but I will not be returning to play this season. I’ve spent hours in the gym every day with the sole goal of coming back, and ‘disappointed’ isn’t a big enough word to describe how I feel.” The announcement marks a challenging chapter for the 23-year-old phenom, whose meteoric rise has reshaped women’s basketball.
From shattering NCAA records at Iowa to leading the WNBA in assists (8.4 per game) as a rookie in 2024, Clark has been a transformative force. Her second season, however, has been defined by physical setbacks, halting the momentum of a player who sparked the “Caitlin Clark Effect,” boosting league attendance and viewership.
Yet, history shows that early-career obstacles do not define an athlete’s legacy. Countless sports icons have faced significant disruptions in their second professional season-whether due to injuries, personal challenges, or external pressures-and returned to achieve championship glory.
Athletes who triumphed after second-season setbacks
We explore the stories of six such athletes from various sports who overcame second-season setbacks to cement their legacies with titles. Their journeys offer a roadmap for Clark’s potential comeback in 2026, illustrating how resilience, dedication, and talent can turn adversity into triumph.
1. Tiger Woods (Golf): From swing struggles to the Tiger Slam
Tiger Woods redefined golf when he turned professional in 1996, culminating in a historic Masters victory in 1997 during his first full season. At just 21, he won by 12 strokes, setting the stage for a career that would change the sport. However, in 1998, his second full season, Woods faced unexpected challenges. Struggling with swing adjustments under intense media scrutiny, he failed to win a major and secured only one PGA Tour victory.
Critics questioned whether his debut was a fluke, and the pressure of being golf’s new superstar weighed heavily. Woods responded with remarkable focus. In 1999, he won eight tournaments, including the PGA Championship, silencing doubters. The following year, he achieved the “Tiger Slam,” capturing four consecutive majors: the 2000 US Open, The Open Championship, PGA Championship, and the 2001 Masters. Woods went on to amass 15 major titles and 82 PGA Tour wins, tying the all-time record. His ability to overcome a sophomore slump through technical refinement and mental toughness offers a powerful example of resilience.
2. Serena Williams (Tennis): From injury woes to Grand Slam dominance
Serena Williams announced her arrival in professional tennis in 1998, but it was in 1999, during her first full season, that she claimed her first Grand Slam at the US Open at age 17. The victory marked her as a future star, but 2000 brought setbacks. Knee and ankle injuries limited her to nine tournaments, forcing multiple withdrawals and preventing her from reaching a Grand Slam final. The physical toll tested her early in her career, raising questions about her durability.
Williams returned in 2001 with renewed vigor, winning titles like Toronto and reaching the US Open final. In 2002, she dominated, capturing three Grand Slam titles-Roland Garros, Wimbledon, and the US Open-en route to becoming world No. 1. Her comeback launched a legendary career that included 23 Grand Slam singles titles, making her one of the greatest athletes in history. Williams’ ability to overcome early injuries through disciplined recovery highlights the importance of patience and perseverance.
3. Jacob deGrom (Baseball – MLB): From limited starts to Cy Young glory
Jacob deGrom debuted with the New York Mets in 2014, earning the National League Rookie of the Year award with his electric pitching. In 2015, his second season, an elbow injury restricted him to just 14 starts, as the Mets cautiously managed his recovery. The limited appearances disrupted his rhythm, though he showed flashes of brilliance in the postseason, helping the Mets reach the World Series. In 2016, deGrom returned as a dominant force, solidifying his status as a staff ace and aiding the Mets’ playoff run.
His perseverance paid off with consecutive Cy Young Awards in 2018 and 2019, recognizing him as the National League’s best pitcher. After undergoing Tommy John surgery in 2023, deGrom joined the Texas Rangers and contributed to their 2024 World Series title. His journey underscores how a pitcher can transform a shortened season into a stepping stone for greatness.
4. Monica Seles (Tennis): From trauma to a final Grand Slam
Monica Seles took the tennis world by storm in 1989, winning Roland Garros in 1990 at age 16. By 1991, her second full season, she dominated with three Grand Slam titles, establishing herself as the world’s top player. However, in 1993, tragedy struck. During a match in Hamburg, Seles was stabbed by a spectator, suffering physical and psychological trauma that sidelined her for over two years. The incident halted a career that seemed destined for unmatched dominance.
Seles’ comeback in 1995 was nothing short of inspiring. She reached the US Open final that year and, in 1996, won the Australian Open, her ninth and final Grand Slam title. Her ability to return after such a devastating setback demonstrates extraordinary resilience, offering a testament to the power of mental and physical recovery.
5. Mike Trout (Baseball – MLB): From minor injuries to MVP dominance
Mike Trout debuted with the Los Angeles Angels in 2011, earning the American League Rookie of the Year award in 2012 with a spectacular season. In 2013, his second full season, minor muscle injuries sidelined him for several weeks, impacting his performance at key moments. Despite playing 157 games, the setbacks prevented him from matching his rookie-year brilliance, and the Angels missed the playoffs.
Trout bounced back in 2014, winning the American League MVP award, a feat he repeated in 2016 and 2019. Widely regarded as one of baseball’s best players, he earned nine All-Star selections and established himself as a generational talent, though team struggles limited his postseason success. Trout’s ability to overcome early injuries and maintain elite performance highlights the importance of consistency and adaptability.
6. Niki Lauda (Formula 1): From near-fatal crash to multiple titles
Niki Lauda joined Formula 1 in 1974 with Ferrari and won his first world championship in 1975, showcasing his precision and tenacity. In 1976, his second season as a top contender, a horrific crash at the Nürburgring left him with severe burns and lung damage, nearly costing him his life.
Lauda missed much of the season but made a miraculous return just six weeks later, narrowly losing the championship by one point to James Hunt. Lauda’s comeback was remarkable. He won the Formula 1 world championship again in 1977 with Ferrari and later in 1984 with McLaren, cementing his legacy as one of the sport’s greatest drivers. His recovery from a life-threatening setback exemplifies unparalleled determination and courage.
Caitlin Clark’s path forward: A champion in the making?
Caitlin Clark’s 2025 season, cut short by injuries, is a detour, not a dead end. At 23, she has already left an indelible mark on the WNBA. In 2024, she led the league in assists (8.4 per game), set a rookie record with the first-ever triple-double by a debutant, and drove unprecedented fan interest, with arenas selling out and TV ratings soaring. In her 13 games in 2025, she averaged 16.5 points, 8.8 assists (second in the league), and 5.0 rebounds, proving her on-court impact despite physical limitations.
Read the full article here
