Caitlin Clark’s return remains one of the biggest question marks heading into the 2025 WNBA postseason. While fans and media eagerly await the Indiana Fever star’s comeback, some analysts argue the team currently lacks the depth to support her return.
Clark has been sidelined since July 15 due to a right groin injury, and a recently revealed bruised ankle has further delayed her recovery. However, the latest updates suggest she’s now running full-court drills without discomfort and could rejoin practice next week.
The Fever have managed to stay competitive in her absence, but a wave of injuries has cast doubt on their ability to make a deep playoff run. That’s why analysts like Ros Gold-Onwude believe it may be time for the team to shift focus toward the future-starting with Clark.
Clark lacks a supporting cast
Gold-Onwude pointed out that Indiana’s recent losses-Sydney Colson, Aari McDonald, and Sophie Cunningham-have all come at the guard position.
“I don’t think the Fever really have enough depth at guard to support a Caitlin Clark comeback,” she said. “Do you even have enough bodies to support that?”
While Kelsey Mitchell has stepped up during Clark’s absence, she’s not a true point guard. Lexie Hull, another option at the position, is currently in a slump. Meanwhile, Odyssey Sims and Shey Peddy-signed on seven-day hardship contracts-are ineligible for postseason play.
This would leave Clark with the sole responsibility of initiating the team’s offense immediately upon her return-out of rhythm and on a roster that has adapted to playing without her. With only eight regular-season games remaining, there may not be enough time for her to regain form.
Looking ahead may be the smart play
Gold-Onwude suggested that Indiana might be better off writing this season off.
“By the time you bring her [Clark] back, there’s barely enough time for her to truly catch a rhythm,” she said. “The season has been honorable for the Fever, but it might be time to look to the future.”
Before her injury-and shortly after returning from a strained left quad–Clark struggled: shooting just 7-of-49 from three-point range over her last seven games, and only 2-of-35 on the road.
As Gold-Onwude emphasized, it may be wiser for Clark to focus on recovery and aim for a triumphant return when the timing is right.
Read the full article here
